Originally published in Student Lawyer , October 2002 (Vol. 31, No. 2) Hot Practice By Lisa Stansky Bankruptcy practice can offer a variety of clients and lots of litigation
work
Bankruptcy is big news— and big business—these days, with the likes of WorldCom, Enron, Kmart, and other large corporations seeking refuge in bankruptcy court. The practice flourishes in a down market, nurtures giant firms and one-lawyer shops, and has room for litigators, corporate lawyers, tax experts, and souls who want to reach out to help everyday folk.
Although you may be tempted to associate bankruptcy mostly with consumer crises, practitioners say that some of the best career opportunities lie with the business side of the practice. And that’s just on the debtor side of the equation. Creditors, too, need legal representation.
Yet another venue for doing bankruptcy work is the nation’s vast network of U.S. bankruptcy courts, some of which have permanent career positions for law clerks.
Some lawyers can’t get enough of bankruptcy practice. "It’s so delicious in terms of its complexity," says Eric Brunstad, vice chair of the business bankruptcy committee of the ABA Section of Business Law.
Brunstad, a partner with Bingham McCutchen in Hartford, Conn., also speaks to the thrill of being a young lawyer in court much of the time, and that doesn’t mean toting some partner’s briefcase. "I was sent off to court a lot to argue motions and other matters," he says, speaking of the early days of his career. Brunstad was just a fourth-year associate when he first argued cases before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit.
"If you want to be a litigator, go into bankruptcy law," says Kathryn Heidt, a law professor at the University of Pittsburgh who, as a young associate, was in court several times a month working on bankruptcy cases. Heidt, chair of the Section of Business Law’s business bankruptcy committee, explains that the often-quick promotion to courtroom work is partly driven by the nature of the practice. This, she says, is especially true for Chapter 11 cases in the business context, which involve significant motion practice.
Aside from the courtroom experience of bankruptcy practice, you’ll also get the immense satisfaction of bringing a business or individual back from the brink of financial doom. "There is no greater high than having that sort of transforming influence on someone’s life," Brunstad says of helping people "get a new lease on life."
U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Manuel Barbosa says he had a skewed view of bankruptcy law as static and dry before he took the bench, because his exposure in practice was limited to straight-up Chapter 7 cases, the most common type of bankruptcy for individuals. From his bench in the Northern District of Illinois in Rockford, he sees richness and variety.
There is a need for quality lawyers to represent consumers, says Barbosa, who heads a bankruptcy judges committee of the ABA Judicial Division. And that’s part of what Atlanta lawyer Shayna Steinfeld does in a varied practice where she represents creditors and debtors, individuals and businesses. A co-chair of the ABA Family Law Section’s bankruptcy committee, Steinfeld has the luxury of handpicking cases in her all-bankruptcy practice. The gray areas of the law, especially in Chapter 11 cases, attract her. "You can argue about anything ... ," she says. "You can be really creative."
As for the tax aspect of bankruptcy, Los Angeles lawyer Mark Wallace says the workload varies, depending on whether the bankruptcy entails liquidation or reorganization. Business reorganizations generate more tax issues, he says, although the practice lately hasn’t assumed that direction.
"Increasingly we’re seeing liquidations rather than reorganizations," says Wallace, of counsel at Stutman Treister & Glatt and co-chair of the ABA Section of Taxation’s bankruptcy task force.
Wallace also says bankruptcy tax practice can be tough to break into. His own career odyssey began with a federal judicial clerkship, which served as a springboard to 12 years of general tax practice with a Phoenix firm, which in turn evolved to the position he’s held for 11 years focusing on the tax angle of bankruptcy.
Steinfeld’s advice for students interested in the field, echoed by other practitioners, is this: Get a judicial clerkship, preferably in federal bankruptcy court, and get in with a firm with a solid bankruptcy practice. "I think bankruptcy is a hard practice to get into straight from school without learning from somebody who really knows the ropes," she says. Practitioners advise students to rack up course work in bankruptcy law, business law, accounting, and secured transactions.
Mike Sigal is a partner with New York’s Simpson Thacher & Bartlett and immediate past chair of the ABA Section of Business Law’s business bankruptcy committee. He says every good bankruptcy lawyer on the business side of the practice has to know the courtroom as well as the boardroom.
"You can’t learn bankruptcy law solely from the books," Sigal says, adding that lawyers need to understand bankruptcy litigation to provide business legal advice. "On the other hand, if you do solely court work, you’re likely to miss the business reality of what’s going on."
Be open to the breadth of the practice from the start, Sigal advises. "It’s important not to be too narrow in your early years, because if you don’t know what a corporation is, if you don’t know how a contract works, how the securities laws work, it’s hard to do the corporate restructuring or a plan of reorganization. You have to have a pretty broad non-specialty non-business familiarity with various areas of law."
Lisa Stansky (nolawritestuff@cs.com) is a lawyer and freelance writer in New Orleans.
To read previous Hot Practice columns, visit www.abanet.org/lsd/stulawyer and click on the Index or Previous Issues links.
Resources on Bankruptcy Law
To learn more about bankruptcy law, check out the ABA Section of Business Law (www.abanet.org/buslaw) and its committees on business bankruptcy and consumer bankruptcy. Click on the "Law Students" link to find out what the section can do for you. Membership in the Business Law Section is free for law students and includes a subscription to The Business Lawyer, a student-edited law journal, and Business Law Today, the section’s magazine.
Also consider the Section of Litigation (www.abanet.org/litigation), especially its bankruptcy and insolvency litigation committee. Students can join the Litigation Section at no charge and receive Litigation, a quarterly magazine, and six issues of Litigation News. Members also can visit the section’s web site and read about section activities in Litigation Docket, and they can gain practical advice from the online Tips from the Trenches.
If you want to represent consumers, look to the Section of Family Law (www.abanet.org/family) and its bankruptcy committee. The section’s web site has a special link for law students. Law student membership in the Family Law Section costs $6.50 a year, providing a subscription to The Family Advocate and Family Law Quarterly. You’ll also have a chance to meet practitioners at the section’s three yearly meetings.
The Section of Intellectual Property Law (www.abanet.org/intelprop) and its special committee on bankruptcy is another useful resource. A $10 student membership includes a subscription to the quarterly Intellectual Property Law Newsletter plus the section’s annual report.
If the tax aspect of bankruptcy appeals to you, take a look at the Section of Taxation (www.abanet.org/tax) and its bankruptcy task force. Join the section for $6 and receive The Tax Lawyer, a quarterly journal, and the annual State and Local Tax Lawyer.
To join an ABA section, call 800-285-2221.