Visit our web site       

Results of First Annual
ABA/IRR Environmental Justice Essay Competition

 

Second Annual Environmental Justice Essay Competition
Environmental Justice Committee and Committee on Native American Concerns
Section of Individual Rights and Responsibilities
Co-Sponsored by the Section of Environment, Energy and Resources
American Bar Association


Many of the sacred lands upon which federally recognized tribes and traditional practitioners depend for spiritual fulfillment, and cultural and political identity lie outside the physical boundaries of reservations – mostly, but not exclusively, on federal lands. In Alaska, where only one tribe has sovereignty over some of its traditional lands, and for non-federally recognized tribes, this is especially true. With growing population pressures, increased interest in outdoor recreation, and continued natural resource development, the Federal Government and attorneys, more generally, frequently face the question posed by this year’s essay competition, “How should sacred lands on federal lands be protected in light of the Bear Lodge Multiple Use Association v. Babbitt?”    

The Section of Individual Rights and Responsibilities and the Section of Environment, Energy and Resources have designed this year's environmental justice essay competition to: (1) increase the level of discourse and understanding about the protection of American Indian/Alaska Native cultural-spiritual resources and issue of environmental justice; and (2) encourage student scholarship to the field. The Committees gratefully acknowledges the generous support of the law firm of Beveridge & Diamond, P.C., and Benjamin Wilson, Esq., and Steven Herman, Esq.
 

Topic
  • Environmental Justice and Tribal Cultural-Spiritual Properties: Protecting Sacred Sites on Federal Lands after Bear Lodge Multiple Use Association v. Babbitt.
Prize
  • First Prize: $1,000 and publication of the essay in the Boston College Environmental Affairs Law Review.

     

  • Second and Third Prizes: $500 and online publication through the ABA.
     
Rules:
  1. Eligibility- The competition is open to currently enrolled students of ABA-accredited law schools. Only original, non-published essays written during the 2003-04 academic year will be considered. Papers submitted for course requirements are eligible for entry. Each entrant may submit only one paper.

     

  2. Authorship- Each essay must be authored by only one student. Jointly written papers will not be accepted.

     

  3. Format- Essays must be between twenty to thirty pages in length, inclusive of notes, double-spaced, single sided, 8.5 x 11-inch paper. Essay style must conform to the current edition of The Bluebook: A Uniform System of Citation.

     

  4. Registration- Potential entrants must register their intent to participate in the competition by April 12, 2004, by notifying the essay competition manager, Tanya Terrell-Collier, Esq., at the address below.

     

  5. Deadline- Submissions must be postmarked or e-mailed no later May 5, 2004.

     

  6. Submission- Papers must be submitted either online in MS Word or in hard copy at the appropriate address below. Each submission must include the following information about the author: (a) name; (b) law school; (c) telephone number; (d) mailing address; and (e) e-mail address. Papers will not be returned to authors.

     

  7. Publication Rights- Each submission must be accompanied by a letter certifying that the essay has not been published previously, that it is of the student's work only, and that Boston College Law School and the American Bar Association have independent, exclusive rights of publication, should the essay be selected as one of the top three in the competition.

     

  8. Judging Criteria- Essays will be evaluated on the basis of four criteria: (1) clarity of expression (organization, presentation, grammar, and adherence to the current edition of The Bluebook: A Uniform System of Citation); (2) originality; (3) depth and quality of research and analysis; and (4) relevance (timeliness, contribution to the field). Judges' evaluations will not be made available to entrants or the public.

     

  9. Competition Address- Registrations, submissions, or questions must sent either by:
    (1) mail: Tanya Terrell-Collier, Director, Section of Individual Rights and Responsibilities, ABA 740 15th St., NW, Washington DC 20005-1009; or
    (2) e-mail: TerrellT@staff.abanet.org; Attn: Essay Competition.

     

  10. Finality of Decision- Decisions of the judges concerning the competition are final.


     

 

Return