Spring Supplement 2009
Joint Newsletter of the ABA Section of Business Law
Committees on Commercial Finance and Uniform Commercial Code
  Commercial Law Newsletter
JOIN THE COMMERCIAL FINANCE COMMITTEE ONLINE!
FREE FOR ALL BUSINESS LAW MEMBERS
JOIN THE UNIFORM COMMERCIAL CODE COMMITTEE ONLINE!
FREE FOR ALL BUSINESS LAW MEMBERS

Messages from the Chairs
  Committee on Commercial Finance
  Committee on Uniform Commercial Code

Mark Your Calendars

2009 Section of Business Law Spring Meeting Schedule

Featured Articles
  Summary of International Instruments Relating to Secured Transactions
  Addressing the Challenges of UCC Filing and Searching in Washington, D.C.
  Loan Syndications and Trading: A Recap of 2008
  The Current State of the Bankruptcy Code Safe Harbor Protections for "Financial Contracts"
  Lender Liability: Taking Stock in an Uncertain Time

Synergy Group Report

Committee on Uniform Commercial Code: Spotlight

Committee on Commercial Finance: Subcommittee and Task Force Reports

Committee on Uniform Commercial Code: Subcommittee Reports

Joint Subcommittee and Task Force Reports

Useful Links and Websites

Committee Leadership Rosters

Editorial Board:

Lauren E. Wallace
    Co-Editor (ComFin)
    Venable LLP
    410-244-7770


Christine Gould Hamm
    Co-Editor (ComFin)
    Husch Blackwell Sanders LLP
    816-283-4626


Carol Nulty Doody
    Co-Editor (UCC)
    Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher
    & Flom LLP
    212-735-2595


  Messages from the Chairs
   
Lynn Soukup, Chair Committee on Commercial Finance
Lynn Soukup, Chair, Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP
Vancouver Spring Meeting April 16-18, 2009

We have a full schedule of CLE programs and subcommittee and task force meetings beginning on the morning of Thursday April 16th and ending on the afternoon of Saturday April 18th. The planned schedule is attached. A final schedule with topics for the subcommittee and task force meetings will be distributed closer in time to the meeting date by email to ComFin members.


More...




Stephen Sepinuck, Chair Committee on Uniform Commercial Code
Stephen L. Sepinuck, Chair, Gonzaga University School of Law
The UCC Committee is continually striving to provide its members on a timely basis with important information about developments in commercial law and commercial practice. Anyone with a suggestion for a project the Committee should undertake or with an idea about how the Committee can better fulfill its mission should contact me.

Proposed PEB Commentary

The Permanent Editorial Board for the Uniform Commercial Code has proposed a new commentary relating to UCC sections 4A-502(d) and 4A-503. The proposed commentary provides that neither the originator nor the beneficiary of a funds transfer has any property claim to the value held by an intermediary bank and, therefore, neither a creditor of the originator nor a creditor of the beneficiary may attach that value by levy, garnishment or the like. A full copy of the proposed commentary appears at the end of this column. Anyone wishing to comment on the proposal may do so by May 8. Instructions on where to submit comments are on the first page of the proposal.


More...




back to top ↑

 
  Mark Your Calendars
   
  • April 16-18, 2009 - Business Law Section Spring Meeting - Vancouver, British Columbia
    Please join us in beautiful Vancouver this Spring for over 70 CLE programs, over 300 committee and subcommittee meetings and an exciting spread of social networking events, including CLE programs on the syndicated loan market, national and international insolvency laws, and the annual review of commercial law. For more details please visit the ABA Section of Business Law's 2009 Spring Meeting website.

  • May 4-5, 2009 - Commercial Loan Workouts: Where Credit Meets the Law - Las Vegas, Nevada
    Former ComFin Committee Chair Bob Zadek will present a hands-on, in-depth commercial loan workout conference. Additional information is available here.

  • June 10-12, 2009 - Global Business Law Forum - Hong Kong, China
    The theme for the 2nd Annual Global Business Law Forum will be "legal developments impacting companies doing business in Asia and the Pacific Rim." More information is available here.

  • June 29-30, 2009 - Commercial Loan Workouts: Where Credit Meets the Law - Chicago, Illinois
    In case you missed this CLE in May, former ComFin Committee Chair Bob Zadek will present an encore of his hands-on, in-depth commercial loan workout conference. Additional information is available here.

  • July 30, 2009 - ABA Annual Meeting - Chicago, Illinois
    The 2009 ABA Annual Meeting will be held in the "Windy City." Consistent with previous years, we expect a number of exciting CLE programs, committee and subcommittee meetings and social events. Registration and other information is available here. Please contact your subcommittee or task force chairs to get involved.



back to top ↑

 
  Featured Articles
   
Summary of International Instruments Relating to Secured Transactions
Neil Cohen, Brooklyn Law School and Steve Weise, Proskauer Rose LLP
Several international organizations - The Hague Conference on Private International Law, the International Institute for the Unification of Private Law (UNIDROIT), and the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL) - have been active in preparing instruments that can affect secured transactions and similar financing transactions. Some of these instruments are conventions that have gone into effect with the United States as a "contracting state." Others are conventions not yet in effect because the required number of ratifications has not been achieved. Still others are model laws or "legislative guides" that may influence the development of the law, particularly outside the United States. When these instruments have the force of law, they should be considered by persons engaging in transactions that may be governed by them.


More...


Addressing the Challenges of UCC Filing and Searching in Washington, D.C.
Clare Oliva, National Corporate Research, Ltd.
As lenders and their counsel know, Revised Article 9, §9-307(c), which became effective in July 2001, requires filing in Washington, D.C. for debtors that are not "registered organizations," such as foreign entities, where the chief executive office is located in a jurisdiction that does not have a UCC-type filing/notice system that would give priority over the rights of a lien creditor with respect to the collateral. Less well known, however, is that the D.C. Recorder of Deeds' office has not updated its filing system and procedures to adequately handle on a daily basis the resulting increase in volume of filings. This presents significant challenges that secured lending practitioners need to be aware of and address when filing or searching UCCs in Washington, D.C.


More...


Loan Syndications and Trading: A Recap of 2008
Bridget Marsh and Ted Basta, Loan Syndications and Trading Association
Last year, in an article published in this journal, we gave an overview of the history of the leveraged loan market. We traced not only the growth of the asset class over the past 15 years but the growth of the Loan Syndications and Trading Association (the "LSTA"), the not-for-profit organization for the corporate loan market whose mission is to promote a fair, orderly and efficient corporate loan market. Among our conclusions, we commented that, as 2007 drew to a close, both the primary market and secondary trading market were in a period of flux as borrowers and lenders evaluated the future and noted that the market and the LSTA were entering a more challenging period with loan prices more closely correlated to, and no longer shielded from, the daily price fluctuations of other asset classes.


More...


The Current State of the Bankruptcy Code Safe Harbor Protections for "Financial Contracts"
Richard Levin, Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP
The Bankruptcy Code specially protects "commodity contracts", "forward contracts", "securities contracts", "repurchase agreements" and "swap agreements", as well as related "master netting agreements", as each of those terms is defined in the Code, between the debtor and specified categories of counterparties. Such contracts and agreements are variously referred to as "financial contracts", derivative contracts" or simply "safe harbor contracts." The automatic stay does not apply to the exercise by protected counterparties "of any contractual right...to offset or net out any termination value, payment amount, or other transfer obligation arising under or in connection with 1 or more such agreements."


More...

Lender Liability: Taking Stock in an Uncertain Time
Eugene C. Kim and Gina Giang, Sheppard Mullin Richter & Hampton LLP
Despite several years of little activity in the area of lender liability, the unprecedented slowdown in the global economy and continuing unrest in the credit markets may prove to be fertile ground for disputes between lenders and borrowers, guarantors or other third parties. When lending institutions pursued enforcement remedies in response to widespread defaults in the 1980s and 1990s, they were met by a massive upsurge in claims filed against them. Today, the number of lenders taking enforcement actions is once again on the rise, which may result in a corresponding increase in borrowers challenging and courts probing lender practices.


More...

back to top ↑

 
  Synergy Group Report
   
Neal Kling & Kathleen Hopkins, ComFin Representatives
The inter-bar association Synergy Group representatives Neal Kling and Kathleen Hopkins, working with the ABA Real Property Trusts and Estates Committee, have submitted a proposal to co-sponsor a CLE for Sunday morning August 2nd at the ABA Annual Meeting: "Creative Financing for Troubled Times." The program will address the use of non-traditional financing structures in the current troubled economic times and recent developments regarding these structures. Topics will include Delaware statutory trusts, mezzanine financing, and tenant in common financings. The program will also address limitations on REMICs in negotiating workouts. A preview discussion on this topic will be conducted at the ComFin Real Estate Financing Subcommittee's meeting, Saturday April 18th, at 12:30 - 2:00 p.m at the BLS Spring Meeting.


back to top ↑

 
  Committee on Uniform Commercial Code: Spotlight
   
Spotlight March 2009
George Hisert, Chair, Subcommittee on Letters of Credit

The purpose of this column is to identify some of the most disconcerting judicial decisions interpreting the Uniform Commercial Code or related commercial laws. The purpose of the column is not to be mean. It is not to get judges recalled, law clerks fired, or litigators disciplined for incompetence. Instead, it is to shine a spotlight on analytical errors, and thereby provide practitioners and judges with reason to disregard the opinion.

Summit Resource Group, Inc. v. JLM Chemicals, Inc.,
2008 U.S. Dist. Lexis 104569 (E.D. Mo. 2008)


In this case Summit Resource Group caused the issuance of a standby letter of credit for the benefit of JLM Chemicals to support Summit's obligations to pay invoices issued by JLM for the sale of chemicals. There followed a dispute between Summit and JLM as to whether certain purchase orders placed by Summit had been cancelled. JLM threatened to draw down on the letter of credit to obtain payment for those orders, and Summit sought and obtained a TRO against such a draw. The reported decision is on the motion by Summit to convert the TRO into a preliminary injunction. In its decision on the preliminary injunction, the court very nicely went through the non-letter-of-credit requirements for an injunction, such as Summit's probability of success on the merits, the threat of irrevocable harm absent an injunction, and the balancing of the harm to the parties. The court then concluded that Summit had met its burden of proof and granted a preliminary injunction against JLM drawing on the letter of credit.


More...

back to top ↑

 
  Committee on Commercial Finance: Subcommittee and Task Force Reports
   

back to top ↑

 
  Committee on Uniform Commercial Code: Subcommittee Reports
   

back to top ↑

 
  Joint Subcommittee and Task Force Reports
   

back to top ↑

 
  Useful Links and Websites
  Compiled by Carol Nulty Doody, Uniform Commercial Code Committee Editor
Please find below a list of electronic links that our members may find useful:
  1. The UCCLAW-L listserv, which is sponsored by West Group, publisher of the "UCC Reporting Service." To subscribe to the UCCLAW-L listserv, go to http://lists.washlaw.edu/mailman
    /listinfo/ucclaw-l
    .
  2. U. Penn's archive of NCCUSL final acts and drafts can be accessed at http://www.law.upenn.edu/bll/archives/ulc/ulc.htm.
  3. Pace University's database of CISG United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods decisions can be accessed at http://cisgw3.law.pace.edu.
  4. Gonzaga University's new Commercial Law Center has a variety of links to useful sites and can be accessed at http://www.law.gonzaga.edu/About-Gonzaga-Law/Commercial-Law-Center/default.asp.
  5. The International Association of Commercial Administrators (IACA) maintains links to state model administrative rules (MARS) and contact information for state level UCC administrators. That information can be accessed at http://www.iaca.org.
  6. The Uniform Law Commissioners maintains information regarding legislative reports and information regarding upcoming meetings, including Joint Review Committee for Uniform Commercial Code Article 9. You can access this information at http://www.nccusl.org/Update/.
In addition, the Commercial Finance Committee's Task Force on Surveys of State Commercial Laws website links to surveys of the law of all 50 states (except Connecticut, DC and Puerto Rico).

With your help, our list of electronic resources will continue to grow. Please feel free to forward other electronic resources you would like to see included in future editions of the Commercial Law Newsletter, by sending them to either Christine Gould Hamm, the Commercial Finance Editor, or Carol Nulty Doody, the Uniform Commercial Code Editor.



back to top ↑

 
  Committee Leadership Rosters
   


back to top ↑

 

The Section of Business Law of the American Bar Association
 321 N. Clark Street | Chicago | IL 60654 | 312.988.5588
  Section Staff | businesslaw@abanet.org | www.abanet.org/buslaw
  Copyright © 2009


Your e-mail address will only be used within the ABA and its entities. We do not sell or rent e-mail addresses to anyone outside the ABA.

Update your profile | Unsubscribe | Privacy Policy

American Bar Association | 321 N Clark | Chicago, IL 60654 | 1-800-285-2221